rhea_kirtikar's Timeline

Commented on cool_tanmay's review

RGV Ki Aag, Sholay Ke Naam Par Daag
Ram Gopal Varma Ki Aag

Hey Tanma, The only saving grace I guess for me is Mr Bachan...for whom I can watch any flop plot...rest after reading your detailed review...I have got a clear idea...Thanx for such a nice writeup...:-) Rhea

Reviewed IGNOU

IGNOU--Distance yourself from education

IGNOU...very promising name and status...however reality is just the other way round. Thought one day of enrolling into one of the most normal course. I guess that was when my nightmare started off. It was a 3 year BDP...afterpaying the fees for the first year you are sent study material. One ne...Read more

Like 20

Comments 9

Reviewed Indian Idol 3

Women can't sing?

If there was a voting system for Ms Universe I'm sure Sushmita Sen would be no where near that crown. It was'nt really shocking, but sad to see Ankita getting voted out...esp when we have seen real good female singers getting voted out ...esp when one would compare them to the ones who were stil...Read more

Like 2

Comments 3

Commented on dwivediakash's review

Pachmarhi - God himself lives here....
Pachmarhi

Hi, Your coverage about this place is fantastic..however, details about stay and a little personal touch would do for me. I am in jabalpur and was looking forward to go there loaded with information..nevermind. Thank you...

Commented on Amul's review

Music Review: Aapka... Abhijeet Sawant
Indian Idol

I was waiting for one satisfying review on this before going in for it and you have helped me decide. Thanks...I must also add about a comment that says that you dint play a critic. I guess that the person needs to read your review again. You have mentioned about a number not being that catchy...I g...uess that was a critic comment but put up very well. One doesnt always need to be harsh to be called a good critic. :-DRead More

Commented on abhijeet_waykar's review

Sana is the Best
Indian Idol

Hi There...thank you for posting your comments on my review. To begin with 1) In my review you have commented that if Abhijeet would sing 'Tu Kisna Hai', he would sound like a beggar on the train. Before I go further I would like to tell you... people who sing on the trains do that for their liveli...hood and not to be Indian Idol. So we should try and be a little human and not make a mockery out of that. Secondly Abhijeet is a good singer(whether he is the Idol or not) and we should give him his due respect by not passing such nasty remarks. 2) About Rahul Vaidya and Sonu... I guess Rahul took him as his idol and there is nothing wrong in it. He also sang 'Madhuban mai radhika',”Esan tera hujaye mujpe”, ' Kabhi toa nazar milaoo'...etc which I am sure, after seeing your profound knowledge in music, is not of Sonu in any way. I dont find anything wrong to keep an idol and sing his songs, it is a way of showing respect. 3)About Rahuls comment...that time Sana wasnt what he is today. Everyone commented on everyone in all forms. But Sana has improved and worked his way...so today you can write reviews on him being the idol. But one must also remember if the judges had not intervened then Sana wouldn’t have even been in the finalist list. There was also Amit Tondon who had all the X factor but no talent. So one must look out for blend of both. Rahul was bad mouthed about in the final 3 round which was not a regular practice and also not fair. When you make this statement you also agree that Rahul had commented when he was not aware that there was a hidden camera. I am sure that everyone must be bad mouthing everyone when they are behind the camera, but doing this in front of the country is nothing more then taking sympathy(like a kid complaining to their teachers in school)I personally always found Rahul Vaidya as THE ONE...not necessary my opinion is what our country thinks. Read More

Commented on own review

Sana played dirty...I think
Indian Idol

I reall get your level of understanding music. Thank you for your comments Mr. Waykar...appreciate your time given. Thought of giving my humble comment on your review...please check it out.

Commented on pagalguy395's review

Abhijeet is Indian Idol
Indian Idol

Earlier I thought I was the only one around observing all these foul plays to promote Sana...thanx !!!Now I think there are more like me, who agree. I am sure it should be Abhijeet... I personally wont consider Sana an Indian Idol.

Commented on own review

Sana played dirty...I think
Indian Idol

Thanx Sonal... It means that should he or shouldnt he. I agree on everything about singing where Sana is concerned, but the point is he did complain in front of the entire country which is not fair. Vaidya could have argued but he like a true gentleman decided not too.You should beat someone with... your singing skills and not these kind of cheap things. Its not like what you say...Vaidya went out after Sana complained( I watch it regularly)Vaidya was in the last 2(with Prajakta) cause Sana got the sympathy votes of 'not well' and then after he complained, Vaidya was out in the next round even though he sang beautifully. However, Sana played dirty cause the channel let him play. So its Sony's duty to draw a line I guess lot of ppl would for the stake of 1crr....However, I too am just going to wait and watch.Read More

Commented on truthreall's review

Biased Judges
Indian Idol

Like you rightly said...they are biased towards Sana. I have a review on the finals too. Sana played dirty with Vaidya complaining about not letting him sing, when his throat was bad. I agree with Vaidya about the selection of song, since this was a competitiona and not a charity show. If Sana becom...es the Indian Idol then .....NOT FAIR SONY!!Read More

Commented on own review

Sana played dirty...I think
Indian Idol

Hi Ghazala...We can judge the contestant only if he is a part of the program...personally I dont even know him. You can take it that IDIAN IDOL should have drawn a line on ' no negative comments' or checked their comperor's too. Giving one the latest foottapping song and the other an old number is n...ot fair on the part of the IDIAN IDOL team. It should be afair game...:-)Read More

Reviewed Indian Idol

Sana played dirty...I think

We too, have been watchingIndian Idolfrom the beginning. Rahul?s were always our fav?s. The day Saxena went I did feel bad, but what happened with Vaidya was not natural. If I remember right, Sana had openly accused Vaidya of not letting him sing a song of his choice, cause he had a bad throa...Read more

Like 19

Comments 11

Commented on Backwaters's review

Rahul Vaidya is still the Best
Indian Idol

We too, have been watching this from the begning. Rahul's were always our fav's. The day Saxena went I did feel bad, but what happened with Vaidya was not natural. If I remember right, Sana had openly accused Vaidya of not letting him sing a song of his choice, cause he had a bad throat(this is not ...a charity show). He and also Aman (Calling Vaidya aggresive) showed Vaidya negative. Vaidya had never before come in the last three, but after what Sana did to him I was sure he wouldnt get votes. And that is what exactly happened. He went in the last two, with Prajakta and the next time he was out. I personally feel these kind of personal comments should'nt have been allowed on air. Anyways now that he is out I looked forward to Abhijeet. But once again they played dirty with him too. In the judges choice section the songs given to both were partial. Here again Sana got the better one since he is now what seems Farahs fav. I think and I would let all my friends vote for Abhijeet cause he is humble and deserving. Sana is definately a great singer, but he did an immatured act which does not deserve to be called the INDIAN IDOL. I definately wouldnt look at him as an IDOL...if he does win then I would say we are to blameRead More

Commented on wont_take_nonsense's review

For the Indian idle
Indian Idol

guess ur right with ur views. I beg to differ slightly. I am sure u might have seen lot many beauty contest. Judges in there are not always linked to beauty or fashion. They are from all possible fields. With that you get varied judgement leading to apt opinion. These guys are a package from the gla...mour world making an IDOL and not a playback singer. Where Faraha is concerned I guess one can dance best on rythmic tunes and proven that she is a fantastic dancer her self her sense of music cant be as bad as you potray. Secondly ears are a part of our organs just the way our eyes or nose are like we can sense good smell or a pretty sight so can we, i guess relate to good music...singer. The initial was the 3 judges job and now its on the entire country who I guess have comman Ears to decide. Insulting some one is not good but one must also try and take out good from the bad....if those BESURA singers hadnt participated maybe there was one person out there who was worth it, lost the seat to him. One should understand ones limitations and try to be in his/her boots. Overall its a nice and simple show which has definately given chance toa comman man. And yes this is no charity so the one who deserves will stay. The hyped daughters mother definately created a scenario and I dint find anything artificial about it. If we start looking at things so sheepishly then there is nothing which is geniun today. The whole world too is make belife...Maya you see. :-) So jus lie back and enjoi it...its fun.Read More