MouthShut.com Would Like to Send You Push Notifications. Notification may includes alerts, activities & updates.

OTP Verification

Enter 4-digit code
For Business

You have updated your profile successfully.

Profile Image

Tilak Chatterjee
@tilak64

VERIFY YOUR CONTACT NUMBER

Please enter your valid contact number to receive OTP.

Submit

tilak64's Timeline

Commented on own review

Oct 23, 2006 12:42 PM

I have dwelt with 3 issues very clearly. 1) Regarding Voice of Samir 2) Regarding Unholy Nexus to make samir Champion 3) Regarding the unethical role of Telecom Service Provider (TSP) 1) The voice of samir is more suitable for qawallis rather then melodies song. If comments have been taken from ...authentic singers then the answer would have been YES. His voice is basically not for melodies song. People must remember that knowing musical grammar is not sufficient. To be a versatile singer you need your good voice also not a voice with a crack record. Samir voice is basically a crack record. That’s the reason I feel he is not a versatile singer but a qawalli singer where you need a crack voice. 2) This is a competition. Even If you get 1 vote less you should be out. But this was not happened with samir. Alka and Bappi both pulled samir back in the competition. You must have seen Abhijit kept quiet which shows that he was not happy with the decision. Then will I not say there is a UNHOLY NEXUS to make samir champion. If this was the case then abrakanti should have been called back. But this has not happened. Y? 3) I remember when people asked Lata Mangeskar regarding the voting system she replied that those who are coming through this system will never last long. Her words just showed the truth. What happend to those champions from Indian Idol and Frame Gurukul. Their names have been washed away.Y? The TSPs are earning crores of money and if some unethical people (may be the producers or some of the judges) asked them to concoct the sms result, do you want me to believe that they will not do it? If you see the voting pattern you can immediately find out the unethical move of TSP. I am shocked to see people are more interested in writing fighting between the judges but never think practically. Since from my side I feel there is a nexus so I wanted to give capital punishment to Mr. Singh. Read More

Commented on own review

Oct 23, 2006 12:41 PM

I have dwelt with 3 issues very clearly. 1) Regarding Voice of Samir 2) Regarding Unholy Nexus to make samir Champion 3) Regarding the unethical role of Telecom Service Provider (TSP) 1) The voice of samir is more suitable for qawallis rather then melodies song. If comments have been taken from ...authentic singers then the answer would have been YES. His voice is basically not for melodies song. People must remember that knowing musical grammar is not sufficient. To be a versatile singer you need your good voice also not a voice with a crack record. Samir voice is basically a crack record. That’s the reason I feel he is not a versatile singer but a qawalli singer where you need a crack voice. 2) This is a competition. Even If you get 1 vote less you should be out. But this was not happened with samir. Alka and Bappi both pulled samir back in the competition. You must have seen Abhijit kept quiet which shows that he was not happy with the decision. Then will I not say there is a UNHOLY NEXUS to make samir champion. If this was the case then abrakanti should have been called back. But this has not happened. Y? 3) I remember when people asked Lata Mangeskar regarding the voting system she replied that those who are coming through this system will never last long. Her words just showed the truth. What happend to those champions from Indian Idol and Frame Gurukul. Their names have been washed away.Y? The TSPs are earning crores of money and if some unethical people (may be the producers or some of the judges) asked them to concoct the sms result, do you want me to believe that they will not do it? If you see the voting pattern you can immediately find out the unethical move of TSP. I am shocked to see people are more interested in writing fighting between the judges but never think practically. Since from my side I feel there is a nexus so I wanted to give capital punishment to Mr. Singh. Read More

Reviewed Sa Re Ga Ma

Oct 22, 2006 12:23 AM 4502 Views

(Updated Oct 23, 2006 12:47 PM)

I I have dwelt with 3 issues very clearly. 1) Regarding Voice of Samir 2) Regarding Unholy Nexus to make samir Champion 3) Regarding the unethical role of Telecom Service Provider (TSP) 1) The voice of samir is more suitable for qawallis rather then melodies song. If comments have...Read more

X