MouthShut.com Would Like to Send You Push Notifications. Notification may includes alerts, activities & updates.

OTP Verification

Enter 4-digit code
For Business
MouthShut Logo
Upload Photo
Water Songs Image

MouthShut Score

72%
3.78 

Originality:

×

Upload your product photo

Supported file formats : jpg, png, and jpeg

Address



Contact Number

Cancel

I feel this review is:

Fake
Genuine

To justify genuineness of your review kindly attach purchase proof
No File Selected

Hate the pronunciations
Apr 05, 2007 02:58 PM 1784 Views
(Updated Apr 05, 2007 05:26 PM)

Originality:

Others have praised the album. The music is definitely good quality. But I am here to write about something that I totally hated about it.


This refers to the song Vsiahnav Jan To. Some of you might know there are two'N's in Gujarati, as there are in Marathi. The first the usual N, pronounced with the tip of the tounge towards the front of the palate, as in Naina, etc. The other - let is write it as N: - is spoken with the tip of the tounge towards the end of the palate, near the throat.  There are no words that start with this letter. The Gujarati word for Three, tran:, has this letter at the end.


You have probably guessed where I am going with this. The pronunciations in the bhajan are totally wrong. The correct words are Vaishn:ava Jan To Tene Kahiye.


The male starts with pronouncing the fancy N everywhere. What is worse, Ten:e is a completely different word in Gujarati, and it does not gramatically fit with the rest of sentance. Then, he goes on to say "Peer Paraayee Jaan:e Re". It should be peed, not peer. Peed means pain. Peer has the same meaning in Gujarati as in Urdu, Saint(?).


The female then repeats. She spares us the wrong N in the first word, pronouncing Vaishn:ava Jan. But then decides she too needs anothe fancy N, saying Ten:e for Tene. She too says Peer for Peed and finally wraps up with saying Jaane Re instead of Jaan:e Re. What's the matter, you got tired of the fancy N?


And then the corus kicks in, saying Vaishnav Jan instead of Vaishnav Jan. And thats when I stop the song.


I haven't seen the film. Maybe the film justifies the wrong pronunciations. Maybe there are a bunch of Banarasis trying to learn Gandhiji's favorite bhajan. More likely, it is just an error. But it puts me off for sure.


Upload Photo

Upload Photos


Upload photo files with .jpg, .png and .gif extensions. Image size per photo cannot exceed 10 MB


Comment on this review

Read All Reviews

YOUR RATING ON

Water Songs
1
2
3
4
5
X