I used this rimmel eyeliner pencil 1 month ago and I would like to share that I did not like this product at all because its not worth the price at all. the tip of the pencil to too hard to apply on eyes , it irritates the eyes the whole day. it is noy at all long lasting, the liner smudges very fast wether its water or sear for that matter . it does not have that thick black colour so I could not even apply it properly in 6 strokes . I did not like it at all and would not recommend it further to anyone .