Review : Tum bin ........
Love story of Aryan and Muskan. After the death of Muskan aryan calls her back ,promising her (Muskan's)atma that if she comes back to this world''he will accept her and both of them will live together''.But after the return of Muskan in rn's life as Khushi ,he never cares for her and always thinking about Durga(wife).
Khushi tries to get rn and his love but she fails everytime,and finally dies in saving aryan's life. Beginning is good. Concept(love story based on reincarnation)is good too. The characters rn(vikas bhalla),muskan(jividha),and the girls for Khushi's character at diff ages are also good,but the way you have ended is very bad(it is better to say worst). By seeing the ending I didn't understand that''whether it is a love story of Aryan and Muskan or Aryan and Durga.'' If calling back a dead one back to this world is a mistake,then that mistake is done by Aryan, but the punishment was given to Muskan(Khushi).
If Rn didn't have to wait for Muskan and to marry some other lady,where is the need to call her back and make her to lead such painful life.
Coming to the comedy character Durga,i am using the word comedy because ,she challenges with Khushi(the girl who saved rn's life from police and Tripathi's men) that ''dekh te hi ki tumhare pyar ki jeet hoti hi ya mere vishwaas ki''.If Khushi has not saved Rn's life,she might be leading the life as rn's widow.Everything of that lady (Durga)is over.
The lady delivering heavy dialogues(shaadi,vishwaas ,pati patni ka saath)can't think that she is not born for Aryan nor Muskan,but Khushi is born only for Rn. How can Khushi live without Rn,and if Rn is alive it is because of Khushi(aryan only accepts the fact that ,''Khushi ne apni jaan par khel kar kayi baar meri jaan bachayi hi''),so it is Khushi who has the right over Aryan. Atleast after knowing that Khushi and Aryan have a son,she might have realised that Aryan still loves Khushi,and should have left Aryan.
In a serial based on reincarnation giving more imp to pati,patni's relation is very irritating.After Rn's death Durga tries to marry Hrithwick(at the age of around 45(she is nearly of the age as rn)).Ok that guy's intension was not good ,she comes to know about this and the marriage didn't took place.But after the return of Aryan Durga saying that' 'rn maine tumhe bahut miss kiya,tumhare bina meri zindagi koyi maayina nahi rakhti'',do u think that Durga has really missed Rn?
Coming to Aryan ,this character is having -ve shades if we consider Khushi.Ok ,he has already married Durga and don't want to marry Khushi,that part is ok.Atleast he should have supported Khushi,when all his family members start hating Khushi when she forces rn to marry her''by saying that there is no fault of Khushi in that,as she is born for him ,she is unable to forget him and his love and doing all these''.
(Agar Khushi un logon ka doshi hi to Khushi ka doshi Aryan hi). Even Rn has no answer when Khushi asks him that''galat to ye bhi hi aryan,ki tumne mujhe apne liye is duniya me vaapas bulaaya,lekin tumne mera intzaar nahi kiya,ye jaante huye bhi ki mi sirf tumhare liye is duniya aayi hoon,aur tumhare bagair jee nahi sakti,tumne mera saath chod diya,meri mout ke baad log tumhe paagal karaar nahi diya tha,meri ek jhalak dekh ne ke liye planchet me mujhe bulaate the,aur tumne mujhe is duniya ke usoolonke khilaaf apne liye is duniya me vaapas bulaaya ,kya oh paagalpan nahi tha,attet ke parchayiyon ne kabhi mera peecha nahi choda,pal pal mi mar mar ke jeeti rahi,isi dhar pe maine ne nark dekha aur ye sab kiske liye rn ,sirf tumhare liye'', Aryan simply that''mi tumhari baaton me nahi aanewala'',
It all indicates that it's only Aryan's fault.he is the hero as well as villain of this serial. anything in this,worth watching is Khushi.I stilll remember each and every dialogue of Khushi-
Aryan yaad hi tumne hamare pyar ka vasta diya tha,tumne meri atma se vaada kiya tha. -tum mujhe meri kadmonke aahat se pehchan letethe. -rn mere janm janmonka pyar hi,aur hamesha rahega. -rn kya kabhi aisa ho sakta hi ki tum mujhe bulaao aur mi na aaoon. -rn ke kadam chahe kisi bhi raste pe mud jjaye par us ki manzil mi hoon. -mi sivai aryan ke aur kisi ki nahi ho sakti. -Aryan humara pyar waqt ke saath aur gahera ho gaya hi -pyar ka koyi waqt,seema aur umar nahi hoti.
I like Khushi because''even after leading such painful life for Rn,when Rn rejects her for the sake of Durga ,she still loves him,trying to save his life,always thinking about him and his family members(even when they start hating her).Even after knowing that Khushi is pregnant rn don't say anything and want to be with Durga only. She excuses him for everything and in the last stage want to save Durga's life(the lady who has spoiled her life)for Mahir's sake,and finally sacrifising her life in saving Rn's life.
Some scenes are really irritating-Durga becoming pregnant at that age,and reading the books on baby caring as if she is around 20's and becoming mother for the first time'',and Rn saying in the temple''mi Durga ke bagair jee bhi nahi sakta,Durga hi meri zindagi hi ''.
But after the Death of Durga he accepts Khushi,and when Khushi says that''both of us will forget the past and tries to begin new life'',he happily agrees.But when he comes to know that Durga is alive again going back to Durga....irritating.
The scenes of rn and Durga shown in final episodes were not part of the story(specially shot and shown).Instead of showing rn and Muskan's scenes ,if they have shown Rn and Muskans scenes the story would have been interesting. The scenes between Rn and Durga are irritating because though Durga looks as lady of around 45,the guy rn looks around the age 35(rn romancing with a lady who is elder to him by 10 years,Astitva ek prem kahani).
And instead of concentrating on Durga's looks(almost on a middle aged lady character)you might have concentrated more on Khushi's looks.Because Khushi is the main character even when compared to Aryan.As she is reborn,people will try to concentrate on her,that how she recollects her past,how she will come to know that who she is.And the music(beat) played whenever Khushi comes(recollects her past) is superb.
But the ending should have been in such a way that both(Aryan and Muskan)will die at the end). Even in the title song it is shown that it is Durga who is coming between rn and Muskaan.And Rn's manzil is Khushi(Muskan). Even rn everytime says that''aaj meri raahon me,meri zindagi me Durga hi,hamare zindagi me kuch aise mukaam aaye ki hum doonon ke raasten alag alag hagaye,warna aaj hum doonon ki manzil ek hoti'',''aaj se mi usi raasten pe chaloonga jo raasta Durga ki taraf jaata hi'',but he never says that Durga is his true love or Durga is his manzil.
But the ending they have shown is compleately opposite.They have started it as a love story of aryan and muskan,but ended it as a love story of Rn and Durga. Tum bin is love story of Rn and Muskan but everytime the lovers get separated. The life of Khushi is very painful,lost aryan,lost her son,and lost her life. Everytime Khushi saves Rn's life,but Durga getting Aryan .......is very unfair with Khushi(Muskan).
Conclusion-----good story,good concept,good beginning,good characters(Vikas Bhalla,Jividha,and all the girls who played Khushi's character at different ages),but bad,meaningless,painful,worst ending.
Pros : Khushi and Khushi.............
Cons:
