This product is very good - almost 80% smudge proof. act both kajal & liner. but the problem is to sharp - it need a specialist sharpner along with the product as it is difficult to sharp it with normal pencil sharpner. The price is within reach. Eyes looks perfect with the use of this product. Perfect for all. Soft to apply. It doesnot irritate the eyes. Everyone will fall in love with thi seye product of colorbar.