Response to Gurudev-no-1's review

Posted on Feb 10, 2007 at 11:31 AM under Replies to reviews

By MouthShut - Head - Member Relations

Hi Jasmine By: Gurudev-no-1 | Feb 10, 2007  02:16 PM Jasmine, I know because I have made research on this site and many other websites; not like your start members who are on a mission to produce reviews; I strongly believe the data which you provide in press are incorrect and you don’t know whether you want it to make it a consumer site or a dating site; why do u put such clause in the user agreement that they cannot be part of any other consumer site??? Can you please answer? Please put up a open form to discuss MS if you are democratic. A very high percent of your review are written in certain format and this only suggests they are manufactured- reasons may be many from improving site traffic, popularity and from users side to get the useless stuff like any city to anyity FlighrRjaja tickets. Please put your house in order. Thanks, James Brown

Hi Jasmine By: hatasaawankighata | Feb 14, 2007  11:26 AM (Updated Feb 14, 2007  11:31 AM) I am willing to start up a separate education section. A separate educational section is required to be started where teachers or educators can contribute with their experience and knoweldge which could prove to be helpful for remote students and other inexperienced teachers.

Can't ensure quality thru and thru By: asterix786 | May 05, 2007  07:55 AM Agree with Gurudev. But then again, u can’t ensure quality thru and thru as it’s humanly difficult to monitor. And what’s worse, you can’t stop ppl from manufacturing data. But in the end, they wil be blacklisted by ppl like u. My concern is that the good ones shdn’t run awy looking at the mediocrity around. SO my suggestion Jasmine is this. Make sure, the better, original writers keep coming back to the site. U cld make them ’star writers’, give extra points, redeem their points, and alwys listen and respond to their every little request. This is the only way to keep such a crowd from drifting away. If you can’t stop this attrition rate, you are making yourself redundant which i m sure you wldn’t want to be. The other thing i suggest is that you should also give points to those who comment on the review. Atleast they are a shade better coz they must have some part of the review to comment abt it. Others might just rate a review for more points without even reading it. Just a thot.

asterix786 By: MouthShut | May 05, 2007  09:45 AM Those were some good suggestions. The Star Writers are definitely the more forceful ones and that is why theu are there. I liked your suggestion regarding the comments.

Kamini - Star Writer By: kingCobra | Jun 28, 2007  02:09 PM I cannot resist asking this. Who is THIS MEMBER Kamini ? How does she become a STAR WRITER by writing some baseless, nonsensical, anti -India articles. I remember she was a start writer with just 8 reviews(now 13), what was the yardstick that you used to make her a star writer ?? I mean isnt it the number of reviews, %age of VU reviews etcc....this female does not come close by any count. Is this person real or some alter ego of people on the board of MS, who are hiding behind a anonymous profile and airing their heartfelt views.